Scores of anti-government activists were arrested. Twenty-five leading opposition
activists were on trial, two in their absence, accused of plotting to overthrow the
government; the 23 were initially denied access to lawyers after their arrest and
some said they were tortured. Other unfair trials took place. The authorities restricted
freedom of expression, including by shutting down several websites and political newsletters.
The government suspended board members of an independent human rights organization.
One person was executed.
In April, the King appointed the 23 members of the board of the National Human Rights
Institution, established in November 2009. In September, however, the board’s President
resigned amid disagreement between its members about how the institution should respond
to political arrests.
During 2010, sporadic protests took place in predominantly Shi’a villages against
alleged government discrimination in relation to housing and employment opportunities.
In some cases, protesters blocked highways with burning tyres and threw home-made
petrol bombs at the police and security forces. Hundreds of people were arrested,
particularly in August and September, in connection with protests and riots, including
many leading opposition figures, most from the Shi’a majority community. Many were
allegedly arrested without warrants and held incommunicado for up to two weeks after
arrest.
Independent and Shi’a Islamists won the majority of seats in parliamentary elections
in October.
Trials of people arrested in connection with the protests started; some were marred
by allegations of torture, denial of access to lawyers and other abuses.
The trial began on 28 October before the High Criminal Court in Manama of 25 prominent
activists, most associated with al-Haq, an unauthorized opposition group. They were
charged under the 2006 anti-terrorism law with “forming and funding an illegal organization
with the aim of overthrowing the government and dissolving the constitution” and other
offences. Two of them, who live abroad, were tried in their absence. All were accused
of fomenting protests and inciting public unrest. The 23 arrested were held incommunicado
for two weeks before they were charged. Some told the Public Prosecutor that they
had been tortured and otherwise ill-treated by National Security Agency officials
and had signed “confessions” under duress; several were referred for medical examination,
but a government forensic doctor was reported to have found no physical evidence of
torture. During the initial stages of the trial, defence lawyers complained about
continuing restrictions on their access to their clients, and most of the accused
repudiated their “confessions” and repeated to the court that they had been tortured
or ill-treated. No independent investigation was initiated into the torture allegations,
and only two defendants were referred to an independent medical doctor for examination.
In December, the defence lawyers of the 23 withdrew from the case because the court
ignored their requests, and the defendants refused to recognize or co-operate with
lawyers subsequently appointed. The trial was continuing at the end of the year.
Other trials were held of people accused of murder and burning cars, tyres and other
property while participating in anti-government demonstrations and riots in previous
years. In some, the defendants alleged they had been tortured or ill-treated to make
them “confess”.
In March, the Supreme Appeal Court convicted 19 men accused of killing a police officer
during an anti-government demonstration in 2008 in Karzakan and sentenced them to
three years in prison. In October 2009 a lower court had acquitted them, finding that
there was extensive evidence that the accused had been tortured in pre-trial detention
to force them to “confess”. This finding was ignored by the Supreme Appeal Court.
No steps were taken to investigate the men’s torture allegations.
Other cases of torture were also reported.
Two men, who were detained for the alleged attempted murder in August of a newspaper
editor, were said to have been tortured to obtain detailed confessions used in court.
They were released in December after the victim told the court that they were not
the people who had attacked him.
Several times during the year security forces were reported to have fired shotguns
at protesters and others. In October, the Interior Minister told Amnesty International
that the security forces had tried to contain protests and violence without using
excessive force and that no one had been wounded by their actions.
In March, Ibrahim al-Dumistani and ‘Abdel-‘Aziz Nasheeb, both nurses, were arrested
after they assisted Hussain ‘Ali Hassan al-Sahlawi who had been shot, apparently by
police trying to disperse a protest in Karzakan in which demonstrators had burned
tyres. The injured man said he had not been protesting and was shot by police outside
his home. The nurses were charged with assisting a “cover up” and “abusing their medical
profession”, and quickly released on bail.
Critics of the monarchy and government were warned that they would be prosecuted under
the 2002 Press and Publications Law, which prescribes prison terms for those criticizing
the King or “inciting hatred of the regime”, although no such prosecutions were reported.
The government clamped down further on dissent after the arrest of the 23 opposition
activists. On 28 August, the Public Prosecutor invoked Article 246 of the Penal Code
to prohibit the media and others from publishing or broadcasting information about
the arrests; breaches would be punishable by up to one year in prison. Although no
prosecutions were reported, the government banned and shut down various publications
and blogs. Among them was the Bahrain Online forum, which the Director of the National
Information Agency said in October had been closed because it was deemed to have incited
hatred and violence. He also said that other websites had been blocked because they
had published material that breached Bahraini law, and that newsletters of political
associations had been banned as the law only allows their circulation to members whereas
these had been distributed to the public.
In September, the government suspended the board of the independent NGO Bahrain Human
Rights Society, accusing it of “legal and administrative irregularities” and “co-operating
with illegal organizations”. Shortly before, the NGO had published on their website
allegations of torture relating to the 23 detained Shi’a activists. The government
appointed a temporary administrator, severely compromising the society’s independence.
Several human rights activists were prevented from travelling abroad, although the
government denied that travel bans had been issued against them.
Nabeel Rajab, Director of the Bahrain Centre for Human Rights that was banned in 2004,
was prevented at the border from travelling to Saudi Arabia on 27 September, prompting
international protests. In October, he was allowed to travel.
Foreign migrants, especially domestic workers, continued to be exploited and abused
despite revisions to the kafala (sponsorship system) made in 2009 to enable foreign workers to change jobs without
obtaining their employer’s consent. In several reported cases, employers confiscated
foreign domestic workers’ passports to prevent them seeking alternative employment.
A number of migrant workers were reported to have committed suicide on account of
their poor living and working conditions. Bahraini law affords little protection to
foreign domestic workers; for example, it contains no provisions establishing a minimum
wage or rest time.
At least one person was sentenced to death and one man was executed. As in the previous
10 years, the death penalty was only used against foreign nationals.
In March, Russell Mezan, a Bangladeshi national, was sentenced to death for murdering
a Kuwaiti man. The death sentence was upheld on appeal in October and by the Cassation
Court later in the year.
In July, Jassim Abdulmanan, a Bangladeshi national, was executed. He had been sentenced
in 2007 for murdering another Bangladeshi national in 2005.
In December, Bahrain abstained on a UN General Assembly resolution calling for a worldwide
moratorium on executions.
An Amnesty International delegation visited Bahrain in October for research purposes
and meetings with the government. The delegation observed the first session of the
trial of 23 Shi’a activists arrested in August and September.
Middle East And North Africa View a Country Report
